Like these weren’t going to happen.
(Pssst. They’ve actually already happened about 127 times in my house. So you’ve got some catching up to do!)
When I get out the molds and ask the kids for requests, it’s almost painful to watch Trevor try to decide – like he thinks choosing Cookies and Cream over the Strawberry Jam Popsicles is a complete betrayal that will haunt him for years to come.
So, what do I do? I make both, of course. Because I’m awesome like that.
And secretly, the decision is torture for me, too.
Cookies and Cream Pops
Prep time: 10 minutes
Freeze time: 6 hours
• 2 cups vanilla ice cream
• 2/3 cup milk
• 6 Oreo cookies, crushed
Place ice cream and milk in a blender. Blend until combined. Add in the cookies and give it a quick whirl.
Pour mixture into popsicle molds. Tap the molds firmly on the counter a few times to get rid of any air pockets.
Freeze for 1 hour, place sticks in the molds, and continue to freeze for at least 5 hours.
To remove pops, run hot water over the outsides of the molds for a few seconds, then gently pull the sticks.
Note: this popsicle recipe was created using a standard bar-shaped mold, each holding about 1/3 cup. If you are using a different mold, you might need to adjust the ingredients.
Reader Questions and Reviews
How can one be expected to choose between popsicle flavors, especially when one involves strawberries and the other involves oreos?! Glad you went with the “just have both” method.
I love everything about these!! So awesome!!
Oh my gosh what a decision. But I’d be Oreo all the way. I’m coming over after school, okay??
Seriously, these are the best yet. Oh. My. Goodness.
Now you’ve got me craving a strawberry jam/cookies n cream popsicle mashup. Wouldn’t that be epic?? These look fab, by the way!
this is a crazy good popsicle recipes.. loving that it’s only three ingredients. love anything oreo related so i am definitely craving one of these popsicles right now!
So I’m just gonna move in with you for the rest of the Summer, if that’s alright.
Perfectly alright! I’ll trade you popsicles for doing the dishes, deal?
Loving all of your popsicle recipes! I bought a new popsicle mold this summer and never used it. Oops!
Whaaat? Well get on that! Ha. Hey, better late than never… where I am, it’s still super hot. Summer break is over, but the season sure isn’t!