Chile Relleno Casserole

5 from 216
Read 216 Reviews
Prep 10 minutes
Cook 45 minutes
Servings 8

A cheater version of classic Chile Relleno, this Chile Relleno Casserole is so much easier without any frying. It has layers of gooey cheese and peppers, with puffy clouds of baked eggs on top. So delicious. And crazy simple. Serve it for breakfast, lunch, or dinner!

We absolutely love the flavors of chile relleno as seen in our chile relleno dip and chile relleno soup. And if you want the real thing, don’t miss our step by step guide and video for authentic chile rellenos! More labor intensive, but it’s amazing.

overhead chile relleno casserole in white baking dish

Pin this now to find it later

Pin It

This post may contain affiliate links. If you click on one and make a purchase, we may earn a small commission at no extra cost to you. We only recommend products we genuinely love.

Easy Chili Relleno Casserole Recipe

It wasn’t until well into my adult years when I found out chili relleno casserole wasn’t the “real” way to make chili relleno. My mom made chili relleno fairly often when I was growing up…or so I thought.

Chile rellenos is Spanish for “stuffed peppers.” Traditionally, poblano chiles are stuffed with only cheese (but can also include refried beans, pork, beef, or shredded chicken), they are then battered and fried, and covered with salsa roja. Um…amazing. But, pretty labor intensive. My mom made it more like this casserole with layers of chiles, eggs, and cheese, then baked.

What I love about this casserole is you get all the elements and flavors of classic chile relleno, but it’s so much easier to make and there’s no deep frying. I make it all the time – it’s always a big hit whenever I serve brunch for friends.

Is it Chile Relleno or Chili Relleno?

According to the Chile Pepper Institute at New Mexico State University, the spelling of the word ‘chile’ has a long and varied history. Chile comes from the term chilli that comes from the Aztec, Nahuatl language. According to Jean Andrews the Spanish spelling was later changed to chile by Spanish-speaking Mexicans and chili in the United States. So basically, in my opinion, they’re both ok. It just depends on the region.

chili egg casserole in white dish with serving spatula

Ingredients Needed

You only need a handful of very simple ingredients to make this chili relleno casserole recipe.
(Scroll below to the printable recipe card for details and measurements.)

  • Poblano peppers – The number of peppers you need depends on the size of them. You want enough to make 2 single layers in your baking dish.
  • Cheeses – We use a combination of Monterey Jack cheese and cheddar cheese, freshly shredded off the block for best flavor.
  • Eggs – Eggs are a key ingredient which hold the casserole together and make it thick and filling.
  • Whole milk – Whole milk or 2% is my preference for taste and creaminess.
  • Flour – Just a little all-purpose flour is used to help the casserole hold its form.
  • Baking powder – Gives the egg mixture lift and makes them nice and fluffy!
  • Seasonings – Onion powder, garlic powder, salt, and pepper season the casserole.
  • For serving – We like to serve portions with sour cream, salsa, and fresh chopped cilantro.

Make this dish even easier!

overhead square portion of chile relleno casserole on plate with fork

Video: How to Make Chili Relleno Casserole

To make chili relleno casserole, scroll down to the printable recipe card for details and measurements and don’t miss the video below.

What to Serve with Chili Relleno Casserole

We like to serve portions with sour cream, salsa or pico de gallo, and fresh chopped cilantro. If you hate cilantro, parsley is totally fine. For even more of a meal, it’s great with simple spanish rice.

square portion of chili relleno casserole on plate with fork

Make Ahead and Storing Leftovers

  • To make in advance. This is a great made-ahead dish. You can roast the peppers 1 to 2 days ahead of time and keep them in the fridge until you’re ready to assemble the casserole. You can also assemble the entire dish, and then cover and place in the fridge for up to 24 hours before you bake.
  • Storing leftovers. Let cool completely, then cover the casserole (or put individual portions in an airtight container) and place in the refrigerator for up to 3 days. This also freezes well. Cover in plastic wrap and again in foil and freeze for up to 3 months. Thaw in the fridge reheating in the oven or microwave.

More Mexican Breakfast Recipes:

I hope you love this delicious and easy recipe – be sure to give it a review below! Also don’t forget to follow Belly Full on TikTok, Facebook, Instagram, Pinterest, and YouTube!

5 from 216

Chile Relleno Casserole

Prep: 10 minutes
Cook: 45 minutes
Total: 55 minutes
Servings: 8
A cheater version of classic Chile Relleno, this Chile Relleno Casserole is so much easier without any frying. It has layers of gooey cheese and peppers, with puffy clouds of baked eggs on top. So delicious. And crazy simple. Serve it for breakfast, lunch, or dinner!

Ingredients 

  • 6-8 large poblano peppers, (see note)
  • 2 cups freshly shredded Monterey Jack cheese, , divided
  • 1 cup freshly shredded cheddar cheese, , divided
  • 5 large eggs
  • 1 & 1/2 cups whole milk
  • 3 tablespoons all-purpose flour
  • 1 teaspoon baking powder
  • 1/4 teaspoon onion powder
  • 1/4 teaspoon garlic powder
  • 1/4 teaspoon salt
  • 1/4 teaspoon black pepper
  • sour cream, salsa, and fresh chopped cilantro, , for serving (optional, but recommended)

Instructions 

  • Preheat the oven's broiler and set the rack at about 6 inches from the heat source. Line a baking sheet with aluminum foil. Place peppers on the baking sheet and roast for about 10-15 minutes, using tongs to turn them occasionally, roasting until the skins are blackened and charred.
  • Transfer the roasted peppers to a plastic bag for about 10 minutes, allowing them to steam as they cool. Once they are cool enough to handle, peel off the skin, cut off the stems, open them up and remove the seeds.
  • Preheat oven to 350 degrees F. Lightly coat a 3-quart baking dish with nonstick spray.
  • Lay half of the roasted chiles in the baking dish in a single layer. Sprinkle 1 cup of the jack cheese and 1/2 cup of the cheddar on top. Repeat layers once.
  • In a medium bowl, whisk together the eggs, milk, flour, baking powder, onion powder, garlic powder, salt, and pepper, until thoroughly combined and no lumps of flour remain. Pour mixture evenly over the cheese and chiles.
  • Place in the oven and bake for 45 minutes until puffed up in the center and eggs are set and golden around the edges.
  • Let stand and cool for 5-10 minutes before cutting. Slice into squares and serve with a dollop of sour cream, a little salsa, and freshly chopped cilantro. Enjoy!

Video

Notes

How many peppers to use. The number of peppers you need depends on the size of them. You want enough to make 2 single layers in your baking dish.
Use canned whole chiles instead. Fresh roasted poblano peppers will give this casserole the absolute best flavor, but if you’re in a pinch for time, you can also replace them with 3 to 4 cans (7 ounces each) whole green chilies. Drain them completely, open them up and scrape out the seeds. Proceed with the written recipe. Still totally delicious!

Nutrition

Calories: 271kcal | Carbohydrates: 11g | Protein: 17g | Fat: 18g | Saturated Fat: 10g | Polyunsaturated Fat: 1g | Monounsaturated Fat: 5g | Trans Fat: 1g | Cholesterol: 161mg | Sodium: 328mg | Potassium: 417mg | Fiber: 2g | Sugar: 5g | Vitamin A: 1057IU | Vitamin C: 99mg | Calcium: 419mg | Iron: 1mg

Nutritional information given is an automatic calculation and can vary based on the exact products you use and any changes you make to the recipe. If these numbers are very important to you, I would recommend calculating them yourself.

Save this recipe!
Get this sent to your inbox, plus get new recipes from us every week!
Did you make this? Leave a rating below!

Share this post

About Amy Flanigan

Well, hey there! Amy here, founder and COO at BellyFull. If you’re looking for tried and true, fuss-free, budget-friendly, delicious, every day recipes, you’ve come to the right place.

You May Also Like

Tried this recipe? Tell me how it turned out, or ask a question below!

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Don't forget to click the ⭐ star rating below




339 Comments

  1. Erikaaaa says:

    5 stars
    omg so good! instantly became a top favorite in our house. My family asks me to make it every week since finding this masterpiece. thank you for crafting such a delicious meal c:

  2. Darrell says:

    5 stars
    Chiles Relleno are one of my favorite dishes but the frying is rather tedious. Gave this recipe a try and it is every bit as good as the real thing but with a fraction of the work. Even my wife loved it and she hates anything with peppers.

  3. Cathy M. says:

    5 stars
    Absolutely DELICIOUS and I used canned chilies, so super easy! My husband raved over this dish…..and he never does that. I sent the recipe link out to my family, it’s that good!

  4. Esther S. says:

    5 stars
    I’m very impressed with this recipe! I rarely follow a recipe exactly, so I added shredded roast pork and used diced green chilies instead of whole. The finished product was so fluffy and delicious! Thank you!

  5. Debbie says:

    5 stars
    Great recipe! I roasted my poblano peppers a couple days ahead and stored refrigerated in an airtight container.
    Even with peppers done a head of time, I’d say to allow 20. -30 min to prepare.
    I also made this with King Arthur all purpose 1:1 gluten free flour, and it was delicious! Made it for a crowd, so I made 2 casseroles, both gluten free and everyone loved it!
    I roasted 12 good size peppers, and they were so good, but I’d roast 16 next time for 2 casseroles . Recipe did suggest 12-16 for a double recipe.

  6. Barbara Hallett Wegner says:

    I have 3 egg whites left over can I use them and a couple of eggs and if so should slightly beat the whites? This looks so yummy

    1. Amy@BellyFull says:

      Hi Barbara – I don’t quite understand what you’re asking? You have extra egg whites and whole eggs and want to know if you can add them to the casserole?

  7. Barbara says:

    5 stars
    I love this, but I adapt it to make a one dish dinner by putting in a layer of cooked hamburger and chorizo. So good!

  8. carl hadley says:

    5 stars
    Outstanding! you were right. it was easy and delicious. the two of us give you 4 thumbs up. thank you!

  9. Pam Winn says:

    5 stars
    I used roasted Hatch chilies and the casserole was a big thumbs up from my husband and professional chef son! I did increase the amount of garlic and onion powder and used cayenne instead of black pepper. Really delicious!,

    1. Bev says:

      5 stars
      This casserole is absolutely “THE BEST”!!!
      So easy-to-make and delicious! Definitely
      our #1, go-to meal. Thank you!!!

  10. Linda G says:

    5 stars
    I had serrano peppers from my garden to use, and they were excellent in this dish. Our family loved it and it will definitely be a “go-to” especially to use with our garden peppers.

  11. Linda says:

    5 stars
    This saved supper! My hatch chiles were too thin to stuff with cheese; they kept tearing and shredding. I googled for an alternative and came across your relleno casserole recipe. I also used some leftover smoked brisket. This casserole was delicious, and so much simpler than making traditional rellenos. A keeper for sure. Thanks

  12. CONNIE YARINA says:

    5 stars
    This recipe is fantastic. I added one 12.5 ounce can of Chunk Chicken Breast in water. I drained the water and chopped up chicken in a small bowl. Then I also added a 16 oz. Jar of salsa. I drained all the juice from it, then added that to the chopped chicken. If it’s to dry add some of the juice that you drained. Then I just followed the instructions. Turned out great.
    I give this recipe 5 stars

  13. Cal says:

    5 stars
    Great recipe. I’ll definitely make it again!

  14. Gail Cannon says:

    Anyone ever add shredded chicken to this?

    1. Claudia Shurtz says:

      Yes! I put the chicken on top of the cheese layer in the middle. It’s delicious! I’m getting ready to try it with shredded pork shoulder.

  15. Ann R says:

    5 stars
    Really good and easy! We grow our own Poblano peppers and I was looking for something simple to do with them tonight. This was the perfect recipe. I didn’t have jack cheese on hand, so I used a really mild feta that both my husband & I love. It’s surprisingly similar to a Mexican crumble cheese.

  16. MT says:

    5 stars
    This was really good! I added tofu, mushrooms and onions to the mix.

  17. Kay says:

    5 stars
    It was Very good! I made it as written.

  18. Colleen Collins says:

    5 stars
    So delicious! We only had 2 (on the large size) poblano peppers, so we cut down on the rest of the ingredients, and it was great! Will definitely make again.

  19. Cathy McDaniel says:

    5 stars
    My husband instantly loved it – and he’s picky. I was strongly encouraged to put this in the line up for holiday and special brunches. I loved it as well (I am not any kind of cook) – this recipe is a keeper!

  20. T.A.Z says:

    5 stars
    This FANTASTIC with Hatch chile peppers when they are in season, if you are lucky enough to get your hands on fresh ones!! My go-to recipe every year. Thank you so much!!

  21. PATRICIA BARNES says:

    5 stars
    Made with Anaheim peppers and topped at serving with pico and spicy cheese sauce.
    It was terrific! Also used seasoned ground beef in the layers.

  22. Kelli says:

    I plan to make and freeze as dinner prep. Will eat in a couple months. At what step should I freeze everything? Before or after baking?

    1. Amy@BellyFull says:

      I would freeze it before baking. Let it thaw in the fridge and add a few minutes or so to the cook time if the casserole dish is cold.

  23. Jacquie says:

    5 stars
    Amazing recipe! Made this last night with Spanish Rice and my husband couldn’t stop talking about how good this was. Hubby always orders Chile Relleno and this, according to him, was better than he has had at restaurants! I used a bit more cheese, canned chiles (one large can but it wasn’t really enough so I had to add some chopped Chile, next time would get one large and two small cans of the whole chiles). Also made this ahead of time (couple of hours) which really made it easy so it was cooking while I was getting the rice ready. BRAVO!!!!

  24. Aimee says:

    5 stars
    My husband and I loved this. Served with some salsa and sour cream. Easy and delicious!

  25. Cindy says:

    5 stars
    Best chili relleno casserole ever and I’ve tried a lot!! Thank you

  26. Melanie says:

    5 stars
    We love this recipe! I have been making it for about 2-3 years but I had to make some changes for a family member. I cut the stems off, cut pepper longways and remove seeds before roasting. Then after roasting only leave them steaming for about 5 minutes before removing skins then cut the peppers into bite sized pieces. My family member is afraid of seeds so every single one has to go! Also bite sized pieces of pepper easier to eat for them.

  27. kathryn yateman says:

    5 stars
    just like the one I ate growing up!

  28. Karen says:

    5 stars
    Best ever and so easy…I prep my peppers in advance and freeze for convenience, so DELISH!

  29. Happy says:

    5 stars
    very easy to make got a lot of compliments

  30. Lindy says:

    5 stars
    What a fantastic recipe and so much easier than making chile relleno from scratch. We all loved it!

  31. Donna says:

    5 stars
    Very good – years ago I used to make this all the time, but lost the recipe. Funny, but wanting to used canned chiles, I found them on Amazon and ordered four cans (thinking they were those little bitty 6 oz cans I used to use) only to get four ONE POUND cans! (Each can is enough to make this recipe twice.). So I hope my family likes it, we’re going to be having this frequently until all the chiles are used up!

  32. Francie Epperson says:

    I’m making this recipe today. When you say to lay the poblanos in a single layer…..do you mean a single pepper as a layer (even though it’s actually two layers, or do you mean to splay the pepper out so it is actually 1 layer? Thanks! Excited to try it!

    1. Amy@BellyFull says:

      Flatten all the peppers so they’re in a single layer, not stacked. You’ll do that twice.

  33. JC says:

    5 stars
    This was so YUMMY!

  34. Julia Esther Contreras says:

    5 stars
    WE really enjoyed this I did not think he would like it but he said its a keeper. So now I am passing it to family members. Thank you for sharing it. Keep them coming.

  35. teresa lvrecipes says:

    5 stars
    Ever since I tried this recipe the first time a year ago, I have made it numerous times! It’s a great casserole for potlucks and dinner time!

  36. Tina Shouse says:

    5 stars
    Loved this recipe. Saved me a lot of time. I roasted my own pepper over open gas stove sweat them in plastic bag for ten minutes then filled quick easy instructions,I decide to use some Las Palmas red enchilada sauce to drizzle over final product. Making your own sauce is easy dried red chilies chicken broth and a little crushed garlic salt and pepper super tasty. Loved loved loved!!! Everyone loved it! Super simple.

  37. Patricia says:

    5 stars
    great recipe

  38. Cheryl Gallant says:

    5 stars
    Best ever! I was delighted with the turnout.

  39. Alison M. says:

    5 stars
    Thank you for sharing your recipe! I had one similar that somehow disapearred from my files. Only differences I made: I had 12 goodsized pablanos. I put a small amount of the egg batter in the greased pan before layering. I find this give a small “base” to the cassarole. Didn’t want to open a big can of enchilada sauce, used a drainded can of Rotel type tomatoes with a little cheese. Was very good and set up beautifully! Thank you again.

  40. J.L.S. says:

    This sounds wonderful and I plan to make it soon as a test. If we love it, I want to take it in an ice chest on a 7 hour drive from home for an event. How do you think it will work if I prepare through step four and then finish it up with the eggs, milk, flour mixture, and bake it when I arrive at my destination?

    1. Amy@BellyFull says:

      Hm. I think that would be fine? I’ve never tested this.

  41. Gayle LaFratta says:

    I am making this recipe for tomorrow. Can I partially cook it tonight and then tomorrow finish cooking it

    1. Amy@BellyFull says:

      No, I would not recommend that.

  42. Lindsey says:

    5 stars
    Love this so much! I have made it many times! I just introduced it to friends and they took it home also! Thank you!

  43. Deb Loftis says:

    5 stars
    One of our favorite recipes!

  44. kay klose says:

    5 stars
    Just served 16 ! Great recipe!

  45. Ginny Huking says:

    I have made this with a similar recipe.I always spray the peppers with oil before roasting. I think it helps to loosen the skin. Will be trying this recipe, hoping that egg prices come down a bit.

  46. SW says:

    5 stars
    I would give this recipe 10 stars if I could

  47. Maryanne says:

    Can I use 1%milk?

    1. Amy@BellyFull says:

      Whole milk will deliver the best results, but 1% might be ok, the custard will be thinner so you might not need quite as much.

  48. Sue T. says:

    5 stars
    Made this for a New Year’s brunch and everyone raved about it

  49. Elaine Koons says:

    5 stars
    I make this at least twice a month. It’s one of my favorites!!

  50. gEORGINA says:

    5 stars
    tHIS WAS YUMMY, WILL MAKE AGAIN. MY FAMILY LOVED IT.

  51. Lainy H says:

    5 stars
    Best chili relleno casserole I’ve ever had. Easy to make, especially since I used canned whole chilis.

  52. Linda Foulks says:

    5 stars
    This is my second time making this and I guarantee it won’t be the last.

  53. Carolyn Ronk says:

    5 stars
    made this yummy casserole today and it’s a hit ! The flavors were perfect together and I will make again

  54. Pura Vida says:

    5 stars
    Great recipe! I did edit a bit. I
    used canned chiles and actually just whipped 4 egg whites instead of the whole eggs because that is how my mom would make her chile relleno batter. I also used 1 cup of plain Greek yogurt instead of whole milk. It fluffed up like a souffle. Tasted great with a nice smother of salsa over the top to finish in the last 5 min of cooking!

    1. Rachel says:

      Do you know if I can use self rising flour instead and omit the baking powder?

      1. Amy@BellyFull says:

        I haven’t tested it, but that should be fine.

  55. Thank you, Gina Hope says:

    5 stars
    Love this. Carb friendly too

  56. Elaine Koons says:

    5 stars
    I love this recipe!!!!

    1. Elaine Koons says:

      5 stars
      This is so good!!

  57. Bea says:

    5 stars
    very good thanks!

  58. teresa lvrecipes says:

    5 stars
    I make this recipe at least once a month. It’s the best!

  59. Ray says:

    5 stars
    This was GREAT. Worth the time to roast the chiles and it wasn’t difficult at all.

  60. JD says:

    5 stars
    Great recipe! Easy and fast. Add breakfast sausage for a wonderful breakfast.

  61. Pat says:

    Can you leave out the flour for non gluten eating folks?

  62. Dari says:

    5 stars
    Made this last night for me n hubby. Loved it! Roasted peppers on stove! Thank you Amy?

  63. Tara J says:

    5 stars
    I loved this recipe it turned out perfectly seasoned with delightful crusty edges…yum!

  64. Glen B says:

    5 stars
    This is so good! I made a homemade tomatillo/sour-cream sauce to top it and I addd a pound of ground beef and an onion seasoned with cumin. Tasty!

  65. Rhonda says:

    5 stars
    I love making chile rellenos and this recipe was quite simple and easy to to do I’m excited about it I will be making again thank you so much

  66. Denise says:

    5 stars
    I added chopped shrimp. It was delicious. Thank you.

  67. Susan says:

    5 stars
    Everyone loved it! Next time I, I’ll prepare the peppers ahead of time to speed up the preparation. Looking forward to making it again, yummy. Thanks for sharing.

  68. Julie Lewis says:

    5 stars
    As with all of your recipes this one is delicious. My 84 year old mother loves it!!

  69. Toni & Cassie Williams says:

    5 stars
    My daughter and I made this today using the canned peppers. It was amazing!! Ok, so my daughter did most of the work which made it even more amazing!! ?

  70. TexieP says:

    5 stars
    Just served this to friends tonight and we all loved it. I had some baby Bella mushrooms I needed to use so rough chopped them and sauteed with onion to add to the middle layer. You could also add chopped cooked chicken, ground beef, or use sausage and make it a breakfast casserole. Just delicious!

  71. Nerissa says:

    5 stars
    Amazing

  72. Susan says:

    5 stars
    Made this today. Layers included ground meat & chopped onions, corn, cheese. Delish!

  73. Tina says:

    5 stars
    Had to use Gluten Free flour and it turned out great. My sister made a corn salad and a bean dip and it was a perfect summer meal. Oh, and we paired it with a jalapeno lemon drop martini. Yum. Next time (and there will be many next times), I think I’ll warm some green enchilada sauce to drizzle over it.

  74. Susan Scrimshaw says:

    5 stars
    I grew up in Guatemala and chiles rellenos are a favorite food. This recipe recreates the best of the original taste and texture with less fuss and no frying. One alternate preparation: In Guatemala, chiles rellenos are filled with carne picada or shredded meat, not cheese. For those who can’t eat cheese, shred some cooked pork or chicken with a few peas and chopped carrots and use that instead of cheese.

  75. Tami says:

    5 stars
    I made this tonight, it’s so good!!! And easy to make.

  76. Barbara Sue says:

    5 stars
    This is a VERY good chili relleno casserole. I want to make this again tonight for a potluck but am thinking of adding fresh corn off the cob before baking. Maybe even blister corn before removing from cob. In your expert opinion would this work with recipe as is or should I add more flour?

    1. Amy@BellyFull says:

      I think the addition of corn would be delicious and I don’t think you need to add more flour.

      1. Jill says:

        Can you freeze this casseroles?

        1. Amy@Bellyfull says:

          Hi Jill – All storage information is included in the article above the recipe card. Enjoy!

  77. Susan B says:

    5 stars
    I made it and it was delicious fresh poblanos and it was delicious, Next time, I might add another egg.

  78. Susan Maestas says:

    5 stars
    Excellent recipe. I’ll never make regular chile rellenos.

  79. Lois says:

    5 stars
    I often eat chili rellano at Mexican restaurants but never tried at home, until now . Excellent and easy!

  80. Lorri says:

    5 stars
    I had to make this tw

  81. Bill says:

    4 stars
    Flavor was great, would like it to have risen more.

  82. Kat Len says:

    5 stars
    Quick, easy & so tasty! I used mild hatch chiles so it was not too spicy. I wanted a meatless dish & this was perfect. To complete the meal I had a mixed green salad & some fruit. Will definitely be making this again.

  83. Maggie R says:

    5 stars
    Thank you Amy. The Chile Relleno is delicious ! I added seasoned beef and a garnish of sliced, seeded tomatoes and black olives. Thank you for this wonderful recipe and great instructions. Wish I could attach a photo for you.

  84. Diane says:

    5 stars
    I love Chile Relleno, but it’s a challenge. This was so easy and delicious! And no frying! I will definitely be making this again & again!

  85. Michelle M. says:

    5 stars
    So good! Simple to make, staple ingredients and delicious!

  86. Esmeralda Greenbottom says:

    5 stars
    I’ve prepared and served this ridiculously good version of Chiles Rellenos 3 times now. EVERYONE loves them. Their puffy, cheesy deliciousness brings tears of joy.
    Yum. And thank you.

  87. LJN says:

    5 stars
    Speechless. So good. Made it several times. No more with the fried version. Thank you for postibg this recipe. So yummy!

  88. colette says:

    wondering if I can double this recipe and put it in an 9×11 pan?

    1. Aubrey says:

      5 stars
      Whole family loved this recipe!

  89. Catrina says:

    My husband and I must really be lightweights, because we found this dish spicy. I made a half-size casserole, broiling and seeding three large pablanos. After we removed half of those as we ate, it had a great flavor. Maybe when I make it again, I’ll use mild canned chilies!

    1. Shannon Huehlefeld says:

      If you can’t handle much heat, remember most of it comes from the seeds a little more from the white separation strips. So clean them well right away, before you do anything, and they won’t be hot just good flavor. Same is true of jalapeños but they are hotter and still retain some heat. Anyone should be able to eat pablanos as ling as they’re cleaned out real well before cooking. I hope that helps : )

    2. Susan says:

      Just use less fresh ones..

      1. Patricia says:

        5 stars
        It’s just my husband and I so I cut the recipe in half but did add a little fried spam that I had in the fridge, it turned out great!

  90. Rae Wagner says:

    5 stars
    Very tasting brunch recipe. I could not get the whole Pablano peppers so I substituted the chopped chilies in the can…two small cans per layer. My family loved it!

  91. Collismom says:

    5 stars
    I have made this recipe many times now and it never disappoints. Along the way, my cupboards have required a tweek now and again. Changing up and doubling the cheese worked for us. Careful skinning the poblanos – don’t leave them steaming for longer than 8 to 10 min or they overcook – In my opinion. The classic recipe with pepper jack cheese added is our favorite

  92. Lisa says:

    5 stars
    Made this, baked in 8X8, 45 mins. Delicious!!!

  93. Barbara G says:

    5 stars
    Easy, yummy, and nice to look at.

  94. Stephen says:

    5 stars
    I made this for the second time tonight. I added 2 small cans of sliced olives and a half an onion, minced in layers over the cheese. Really added to the complexity of the flavor and turned out beautifully. Definitely on my list of regulars.

  95. Araceli Rodriguez says:

    5 stars
    I picked this recipe because you make Chile’s Rellenos the way my mother makes them. I already know it is going to be good. Thank you.

  96. Mania says:

    5 stars
    This was so so good! I love traditional stuffed chile rellenos but this was a great way to get all the flavors without all the work. Highly recommend this recipe.

  97. Pat Drenowatz says:

    Could this recipe be halved for an 8×8” baking dish? Just my husband & I ?

    1. Amy@Bellyfull says:

      Hi Pat – I’m sure that would be fine. You might need to adjust the bake time a bit. Enjoy!

  98. Joanne says:

    Do you recommend any changes & long this should be baked if I only make half the recipe?

    1. Amy@BellyFull says:

      I’ve never halved this recipe, but it will most likely still need the same bake time for the eggs to cook and set properly. It will also depend on the size/depth of the pan you use.

  99. Cindie Ward says:

    5 stars
    Made a 1/2 size of this with roasted hatch peppers. Awesome!

    1. Lisa says:

      How long did you bake it?

  100. Vickie Akin says:

    5 stars
    I made this tonight. Spectacular!
    I will be making this again for sure

  101. Sandi says:

    5 stars
    This was so good my stepson ate half of it ?. I used canned chilies and evaporated milk and baked it in a 7” x 11 baking dish. It’s a keeper I’ll be making often.

  102. Cherie says:

    5 stars
    Made it exactly as directed. This is a new favorite and I will be making it often! Easy and delicious!

    1. Sylvia says:

      5 stars
      This recipe is so easy and delucious. I roasted fresh poblano chilies, peeled them , and followed the instructions. I madechalf a recipe in 8×8 dish and baked for 45 mins. Excellent flavor and nice fluffy egg coating. I love this recipe and will be making it again. Thank you for sharing.

  103. Pam says:

    5 stars
    Excellent!! Breakfast, lunch, or dinner!

  104. Zoe says:

    5 stars
    Very easy and delicious. Did not change anything-love the puff in the eggs, so fluffy. We toped it with avocado, cilantro & jared salsa. This will be a regular monthly dish.

  105. KATHERINE says:

    5 stars
    This is a great recipe!! I did add jalapeños on half but, other than that I didn’t change the recipe. Sooooo goooood

  106. Tina says:

    5 stars
    This is such a great recipe. I’ve made it with fresh chiles and also canned when I need a shortcut. We all love it. So easy and delicious.

  107. Theresa Capri says:

    Oh and I forgot to mention, after it was out of the oven, I topped with extra homemade queso fresco I made a few days ago and it was perfect to mitigate the spiciness since I left a few of the seeds when cleaning the peppers.

  108. Theresa Capri says:

    5 stars
    This was very yummy! I had about a dozen smaller diameter peppers from my brother’s garden, but filled in with red bell pepper like someone else mentioned. Everything else the same, except I just sliced the cheeses off the brick instead of shredding it. I was thinking at first the 3 qt pan that the recipe called for might be too big, but it wasn’t. I appreciated the details you gave for roasting the peppers. Thanks for the recipe! Definitely will make again!

  109. Jeanne Pratt says:

    5 stars
    I took this to friends for dinner to accompany a taco bar. Everyone loved it! There were no leftovers. I will make this again and again! Thanks for a terrific easy recipe!

  110. Kevin says:

    Do you think I can use buttermilk instead of whole milk?

    1. Amy@BellyFull says:

      Hi Kevin – I would not use buttermilk in this recipe.

    2. Jill says:

      5 stars
      Hey Kevin, not buttermilk, but I’ve used half and half cream and whip cream for added richness

  111. Robert says:

    5 stars
    This is a great dish. I used Poblano peppers and a blend of Mexican cheese. I also made New Mexico green chilli sauce and homemade refried beans as additions.

  112. Ms Holls says:

    5 stars
    I had two poblanos and really wanted rellenos but not worth the effort of frying for two. Found this recipe and made an individual portion with ingredients cut, in a ramekin. Great lunch, will definitely make again.

  113. Kay says:

    Could Hatch green chiles be substituted for poblanos?

    1. Amy@BellyFull says:

      Probably, try it!

      1. Jill says:

        5 stars
        My family really enjoyed this dish!! It says you can assemble the casserole 24 hours before baking, but that would activate the baking powder. I assembled the cheese and peppers and measured out the dry ingredients, when ready to bake I mixed the wet and dry then poured it into the dish and baked immediately.

        1. Cindy says:

          Great tip on the make-ahead. Thanks!

    2. Estelle G says:

      Absolutely! Hatch green chiles are preferable to poblanos, but unless you’re in NM or order online like I do, poblano chiles are much easier to find.

  114. Bruce Jacobs says:

    5 stars
    Hello, I will admit I have not tried this recipe. I’m thinking it may work well as a vegetarian appetizer.
    Also, possibly modified with 1/2 the pan using poblanos and the other 1/2 red bell peppers for those sensitive to heat.

  115. Maggie R says:

    5 stars
    So good! I added shredded cooked chicken. This is a winner! Thank you for sharing this recipe!

    1. Jan says:

      5 stars
      This recipe is a favorite! I use 3 of the canned, drained, and is simple. For dinner , we serve with rice a beans.

  116. David says:

    5 stars
    I planted poblano peppers in my garden this year. I used the peppers in this recipe. All I can say is this recipe tasted Fanastic!! I have made this recipe several times and my family loves it. It’s quick, easy, and delicious!!!

  117. Felicia says:

    5 stars
    I love this recipe so much, I’ve made it a dozen times and always comes out so delicious.

  118. Debbie says:

    5 stars
    This one is the best! I’ve tried many recipes for chili rellenos and this was definitely the best. It was simple to make and it turned out exactly as the recipe said it would. I’ll be making this often.

  119. Teri says:

    5 stars
    Very yummy and so easy!

  120. Jeri says:

    5 stars
    This was wonderful!

  121. Carol says:

    I’m going to cut and deseed the poblanos before roasting as I’ve never roasted/broiled peppers before. Hoping that this does not make any difference.

  122. Nancy says:

    5 stars
    This is really good. Next time I will double the peppers. I used a combination of pepper jack and Colby cheese. And I have a gas range so I roasted my peppers over the flame. Will most definitely make again.

  123. Judy says:

    5 stars
    I made a change and used a deep dish pie crust, pre- baked it 15 minutes before adding the egg and chili mixture and then baked it for the stated amount of time. My take on a Chile Rellano quiche. Delish!

  124. Kathrine Whitfield says:

    5 stars
    I love this recipe and have faithfully followed its directions—until today. I’m using Anaheim chilies and hoping they turn out just as well as the poblano chilies. I also added cumin, green chile and chipotle seasonings because my husband likes heat in his southwestern dishes. We’ll see!

    1. Lisa says:

      I also have Anaheim how did it turn out?

  125. Lorri says:

    5 stars
    Delicious.

  126. Susie says:

    5 stars
    This is the best Chile relleno pie recipe I’ve tried-I used 2 7oz cans of fire roasted Chiles because I didn’t have the poblanos,a little less milk but it was so good. I’ll try it next time with poblanos

  127. Jay Bird says:

    5 stars
    Made the Casserole. My local market in Texas once a year roasts Hatch Chilis. Bought a bunch made this casserole, will cut some up and use for scrambled eggs or a fritatta.

    1. Sandy Weaver says:

      5 stars
      I made this and other things for a party and this recipe stood out and the best. Everyone loved it. It’s a keeper. Make your own peppers instead of using canned. It will make all the difference.

  128. Sue says:

    5 stars
    My husband LOVED this!

  129. Mariella says:

    5 stars
    Delicious

  130. Kim says:

    5 stars
    My family loves this recipe so much! We’ve made it both ways – with the roasted chilis from scratch and canned depending how much time I have. Both so good.

  131. Stu says:

    5 stars
    This was GREAT.

  132. Nancy says:

    5 stars
    My favorite

  133. Kitty says:

    5 stars
    This was great! I used fresh chopped garlic and red onion. Also, I am not a fan of dairy so I used coconut milk and cashew cheese. I also added some cumin.

  134. Mickey D says:

    5 stars
    Thanks, the baking powder improved my previous recipe.
    I recommend,
    Using half Anaheim Chiles,
    Peeling them over a bowl and using the juice for an equal amount of milk,
    Cutting the Chiles in 3/4 inch squares.

    1. Lesley says:

      5 stars
      I’m going to make this to take on a vacation with us. I didn’t see a comment about baking powder. Do you exchange it for same amounts of flour?

  135. Beth says:

    5 stars
    Delicious! I added a flour tortilla layer under the chiles and a shredded chicken layer between chiles and cheese, and used chicken broth as the liquid. Served with salsa, sour cream, and cilantro for a lovely dinner with an avocado/orange salad. I love how the technique will work with endless variations. Bravo!! ?

    1. Sue says:

      5 stars
      I made this exactly as stated, the only thing I did was reduce the quantity of ingredients since it’s only my husband and my son left in the house. I even had all the ingredients for pico de gallo, so I served it with sour cream and the pico. It was SO GOOD!!! My husband was very satisfied with it, because my mother-in-law used to make this casserole and I lost her recipe. This is pretty much what she used to make. Thank you for a yummy recipe!

  136. KimberleeT says:

    5 stars
    This is my “go to” chili relleno recipe. It’s very easy, and yummy. I add one extra thing – in between the 1st/2nd layer I add a bit of salsa to give it a hit of heat besides the peppers. I’ve made this for others and they love it too. Yummy!

  137. Kelly says:

    5 stars
    Absolutely delish and loved the use of real poblanos instead of canned green chilies. This was as good leftover as first time too.
    10 stars for sure!

    1. Zach Dickerson says:

      Trying this recipe tomorrow, but I’m gonna add some chorizo ?

  138. Gloria Almendares says:

    5 stars
    Everyone loved this recipe, followed it to a T. Love making your easy and tasty recipes. I’ll be trying out new ones for Easter. Is there one in particular you would like to recommend?
    My Family now has a Full & Happy Belly! Thank you so much!
    P.S. I do live in Hawaii, so any exotic ingredients are non-existent here. Poblano peppers were hard to find (we don’t have any Mexican markets). Can I used canned peppers? I can buy those in CA when I go to visit, twice per year.

  139. Carol Cox says:

    5 stars
    Loved this recipe, it was easy fast. Family loved it. Served with refried beans for supper. Used fresh poblano.

  140. Farmersdaughter says:

    5 stars
    I love this casserole, however, being me I had to change it up a bit. I add a layer of cooked drained breakfast sausage or chorizo over each layer of the peppers. Then I add a layer of tater tots on top of the finished layers and bake until a knife comes out clean and tater tots are golden and crisp. Add some cheese, let it sit in the hot oven for 10 minutes until the cheese melt and serve. I made it like this so I could take it camping and just reheat for a fast, complete, homemade meal at the rodeos my kids competed in.

  141. Sheryl says:

    5 stars
    Delicious! Even with canned pablanos, it was a big hit.

    1. Humbletexan1 says:

      5 stars
      Very requested in our home! In the oven now, again! Great recipe.

  142. Doug Van Beek says:

    5 stars
    Super Easy! Super Good!

  143. Barbara says:

    5 stars
    This was delicious! Will be making it often! Thanks!

  144. Beth says:

    5 stars
    Great recipe. Super good and easy.

  145. catherine says:

    5 stars
    loooooved it!!!

  146. Laura says:

    5 stars
    I love Chile Rellenos. When I saw this recipe it looked like simplified way to make them and still get the flavor. I was right. Now it is a regular on my table when Mexican food is on the menu. Great recipe!

  147. Lisa N says:

    5 stars
    I had an excess of poblanos from my garden so I roasted them, peeled themand canned them. They worked perfectly for this recipe and everyone LOVED it! I’ll be making this again and again!

    1. Johnny says:

      5 stars
      Fabulous Recipe!
      Been craving Chili Rellenoe Casserole for the last few weeks. Excellent recipe will add your recipe to my collection

  148. Debra I says:

    5 stars
    This recipe if fantastic! It will be on my best recipes list from now on. Hubs agreed (after his 3rd helping!) Served with a homemade salsa roja using fresh garden tomatoes.

  149. Wendy says:

    5 stars
    I separated the white and whipped them to very soft peaks and then folded them into the rest of the egg mixture. This is the very best chili relleno casserole I’ve ever tasted. So, so good.

  150. Stacky says:

    5 stars
    My husband and I love this recipe. So easy and delicious.

  151. Jean says:

    5 stars
    Made this for dinner tonight. Very simple recipe. Quality of the peppers is super important. Everyone loved it. Thanks!

  152. Ann says:

    5 stars
    I loved this. As the bottom layer I cooked polenta in the instant pot, layered it on the bottom and baked it for 15 minutes at 350 until just firm. We had some leftover chili verde, so I added that, pepper jack and cheddar.

    I’ve made chili relleno the traditional way, but really, who needs that frustration.

  153. DaNuck says:

    5 stars
    WOW ! I used fresh Hatch Chilies and added a couple layers of lightly fried corn tortillas and Chorizo,,,, YUUUMMMMMMM

  154. Kimberly says:

    5 stars
    Came out perfectly!

  155. Cindy Wilson says:

    5 stars
    I shocked my old school Mom with this recipe!!!!

  156. Dana says:

    5 stars
    Delicious, just the right amount of spice. I think using fresh roasted poblanos is a must. It adds a lot of flavor.

  157. Rea Rae says:

    5 stars
    I learned several years ago, but dipping the chilis in the beaten egg whites and frying is messy and exhausting. I’m using your recipe instead but also taking the time to beat the egg whites and salt separately and folding it into the rest of the whisked ingredients. A little of this airy batter on the bottom and pour the rest on top- voila- baked chili rellenos! To die for. Less work and less cleanup.

    1. Lynn says:

      5 stars
      I forgot the milk! It still came out poofy and delicious..just served with some ranchero sauce, and everyone ate it up.
      I roasted a mix of poblano, Anaheim and jalapeño peppers as directed, a lil tough to get the skins off, but it didn’t seem to matter. Thank you for posting, I love a recipe so good, that it withstands my goofs – will definitely make again, but remember the milk!

  158. Cindy Wilson says:

    5 stars
    I Love this recipe it’s easy to make and Delicious!!!!

  159. Tina Cox says:

    5 stars
    I’m not much of a cook so I don’t try new things often. But this recipe had all ingredients I happened to have on hand after a trip to hatch nm where I picked up the roasted chilies. It was easy and more importantly it was wonderfully delicious!

  160. Jan says:

    5 stars
    I’ve made this recipe over and over and everyone loves it! I mean everyone! I used the whole mild canned peppers as you suggested, for ease. Wonderful easy recipe.

  161. Meaghan says:

    5 stars
    This recipe is a keeper!! I’ve made it so many times I thought I should finally comment. Roasting the peppers definitely adds the best flavor, but I’ve also used the canned chiles and it’s still wonderful! Can’t go wrong either way.

  162. CAROL G NYE says:

    5 stars
    What to do with leftovers?There are no leftovers in our house! This recipes is so-o-o good!!

  163. Barbara says:

    5 stars
    So easy to make whenever I think about making this dish I go through all of my recipes until I find the belly full recipe for chili rellenos. Is easy it’s just delicious and everybody loves it

  164. Camille says:

    5 stars
    So good! Made this tonight with a few changes bc recipes are a guide lol. I saw someone mentioned using sausage and I added a pound of deer sausage and a pound of ground turkey, a small can of jalapeños, and added some chili verde sauce before the egg mixture. Not sure how this effected it but I didn’t have any milk to I added an extra egg and used a cup of water.

  165. Toni says:

    I just put it in the oven and can’t wait to try it! ?

  166. Sharon Cannella says:

    5 stars
    Found this a while ago and made it and loved it. Couldn’t find it again until today. It’s in the oven right now.

  167. Helen Luksan says:

    5 stars
    Love this recipe and all your recipes. Thank you!

  168. Heather Curbow says:

    5 stars
    This was a perfect recipe. I added a layer of sausage as well. I also combined canned and fresh roasted peppers I had on hand. Very adaptable and delicious

  169. Virginia says:

    5 stars
    Excellent recipe! I made it exactly as written. It is a cinch to make and super-satisfying to eat. It is a keeper, so thank you very much.

  170. Vivian says:

    5 stars
    This recipe produces a perfect egg mixture that turn out light. I use just mozzarella as the cheese and poblano peppers that I first blister in an air fryer (you can use an oven) and then peel. Just like chili rellenos – but easier and less fat. I top it with Pace salsa that I cook first either on the stove or microwave.

  171. Chris says:

    4 stars
    I’ve made this twice and really like it. The first time I used Jiffy cornbread mix, second time flour; both worked fine. The biggest change I made was with the milk. I used a large 28 ounce can of chilies, and when I drained it I discovered there was nearly a cup of liquid. This has lots of flavor so rather than throwing it away I mixed it with a can of evaporated milk. I thought the casserole was tasty but bland, so the second time I added a 4 ounce can of chopped jalapeños. This really upped the flavor and is what I will do from now on. Super easy and super delicious!

    1. Johnny says:

      5 stars
      Nice Recipe w great detail!
      Will be adding your recipe to my collections …
      Excellent!

  172. Janet says:

    5 stars
    My entire family LOVED this!

  173. Connie says:

    5 stars
    LOVED this! I used half whole eggs and half just white eggs. Came out great.

  174. Tara says:

    5 stars
    I’ve made this many times! I usually have my own peppers or I buy them fresh from the store and roast them myself. I also add some Cotija cheese and a some small spots of cream cheese in the middle layer. I top it with mild green chili salsa the last 5 min of baking. Soooo good!!

  175. Cathy says:

    5 stars
    Loved this – delicious and so easy.

  176. Carl Hadley says:

    5 stars
    So easy and delicious. Wifey wants it once a week now. glad I found BellyFull.

  177. Diane says:

    5 stars
    I’ve made this several times with fresh roasted peppers, canned, and frozen. Today it’s diced frozen Hatch (from Safeway), thaw and drain before using. I usually add some corn, onion or another crunchy veggie for texture but that’s just for fun. Today had a little sliced turkey breast that needed to be used so threw that it as well. This is a really versatile recipe. And yes, I used 5 eggs and 1 3/4 cup milk. I might reduce the milk a bit if using skim or 2%, but as written it’s fine. I do omit the salt and use sodium free baking powder because of medical diet needs, but there is enough salt in the cheese that no one notices the difference.

  178. Jeanette says:

    5 stars
    Made this two nights in a row last weekend and making it again this weekend. Blistered poblanos myself and used instead of canned.
    Truly love this.

  179. Micky says:

    5 stars
    Hubby & I loved this…so easy!

  180. Tish Gunter says:

    5 stars
    My husband ordered a bunch of chilies from Hatch, NM and I was looking for some recipes to use the chilies in and found yours.. my family loves it so much!!

  181. Carol says:

    5 stars
    Delicious and easy way to serve a group

    1. MJ says:

      5 stars
      Made it many times now making it for more how do I increase for serving 10?

  182. Colleen Hylton Figart says:

    Can I use fresh jalapeños in this recipe?

    1. Amy @Belly Full says:

      As long as they’re roasted and peeled, it should be fine. You’ll need a lot of them, since they’re so small.

    2. Donna says:

      5 stars
      I added 1 lb ground beef, 1/2 chopped onion and 1/2 can jalapeños…yummy

  183. Debbie Saltzman says:

    5 stars
    Fantastic recipe. I’ve made it so many times.

  184. Cdp says:

    5 stars
    Fantastic. Hardest part is getting lg can of Ortega chilies. I order from Amazon.

  185. Ccos says:

    Can I prep this in the morning and cook later in the day?

    1. Amy @Belly Full says:

      Yes, that’s not a problem. Just keep it tightly covered in the refrigerator until you’re ready to bake.

  186. Cheryl says:

    5 stars
    VERY good

  187. Maribeth Bastian says:

    5 stars
    This recipe is has become part of my regular rotation. Even my mother-in-law, who lives with us, loves it … and she’s hard to please! No modifications for us—just top it off with some salsa.

  188. Jannis says:

    5 stars
    I made this last year for a vegetarian friendly dinner party and it was wonderful, everyone loved it. But no dinner parties these covid19 days(daze). But I still want to make this just for me. So, I think I will make a 2/3rds recipe, chop the peppers and bake in a muffin tin, eat my fill and freeze the rest. Wish me luck!

    1. Chris says:

      Ooo, great idea, thanks! I’m making it for the first time today and will use Jiffy corn bread mix instead of flour. I also drained the can of chilies and was surprised to get about a cup of liquid. That contains a lot of the flavor so I added canned milk, also some cumin and frozen corn, otherwise unchanged. Will review after.

  189. Darla says:

    5 stars
    My family LOVED this casserole!! Great flavor! I did make one change. I used ROASTED Poblano peppers vs. canned peppers. I thought this added another level to this delicious recipe!!

    1. Mary says:

      5 stars
      Entire family when bonkers over this recipe – will go in my permanent binder. Thank you for sharing!

  190. Dorie says:

    5 stars
    This so simple and so delicious. A recipe I plan on using again and again and again!

  191. kate Ferguson says:

    5 stars
    Easy, quick and excellent. loved it!

  192. Nichole says:

    5 stars
    I’ve never made chili rellenos before but it’s one of my husband’s favorite Mexican dishes so I gave it a try. OMG, it was delicious! My husband couldn’t stop saying how yummy it was. Definitely a keeper recipe!! ?

  193. pete says:

    Hi Amy,

    Thanks for sharing this delicious recipe. I have made it several times and the family loves it. Does this work well for freezing? Have you (or any readers) tried preparing it and then freezing it before cooking?

    1. Amy @Belly Full says:

      Yep, instructions for freezing are included above the recipe card.

      1. Diana says:

        I freeze it all the time. As there is just the two of us-and one of our favorite meals…I bundle up the leftovers. I do take out of the freezer the day before we are doing to have, so it defrosts b

    2. Shirley says:

      5 stars
      I make it large enough for 2 9″ square pans and freeze one after baking. I also add sliced olives to mine. I prefer using canned milk . This is a go to for me, we love it. At times I brush the top after baking with a bit of hot sauce.

  194. Pat says:

    5 stars
    Family favorite,! Very delicious and extremely easy to prepare .I make this often because it’s so tasty and it comes together so quickly. Some family members like freshly sliced (Hot) jalapeño so I add a few to one side and we’re all happy.

    THANK YOU!!

    1. Felipa says:

      This looks so yummy and I thought I can do this! Until the eggs were mentioned…?
      I am allergic to eggs! I developed an allergy to eggs n milk in my 60s. Do you know what else to substitute?

      1. Amy @Belly Full says:

        Hi Felipa! That’s such a bummer! Unfortunately eggs are a major and critical ingredient in this recipe for it to turn out properly, sorry!

      2. Lyla says:

        Have you tried eggs again i had a friend who was the same allergic but as she got older she tried to eat eggs and found out her body changed

      3. DonnaT says:

        Felipa, I grew up with a mother who was highly allergic to eggs and we learned to adapt quite well. So, although this particular recipe does require eggs, a local Mexican restaurant makes them without the eggs and covers them with a creamy salsa-like sauce. That does make it a different dish, it is quite tasty. You might try playing around with that idea.

      4. Kai says:

        5 stars
        Try using Just Egg. It’s a vegan “egg” product made of Mung Beans. It cooks and tastes 100% like real eggs!

  195. Debbie Erck says:

    5 stars
    We made this several times, love this receipe! I also added about a cup of shredded hash browns potatoes…just because. Turned out great!

  196. Ralph Fiscus Jr says:

    5 stars
    I make a similar dish. I grow my own Anaheim peppers, roast them on the grill, then peal and clean them. I layer mine: peppers, meat, cheese, peppers, meat, cheese. I separate the eggs to whip up the whites to soft peaks, then fold in the yolks, milk, and flour mix. That’s how they do the batter for real chile relleños.

    1. Frank says:

      Your chili rellenos recipe sounds like what I had in mind. I am not sure about baking this recipe verses frying. Do you bake the dish after preparing it or do you lay it all out in a pan, pour the egg mixture over it and fry it like on big chili relleno? This is what I had in mine but I wanted to find out what you do since I believe that with your approach to whiping the whites and adding in egg mixture makes the relleno casserole taste closer to a single fried chili relleno.

    2. Lyla says:

      Do eggs come out better like that cause ur baking

  197. Sanda Everette says:

    I used to make a similar casserole many years ago and had forgotten about it. I was trying to think of something for a potluck tonight and the idea popped back in my head. One change I used to make and I probably will make tonight is when layering the cheese and the peppers I would put a layer of sliced zucchini in as well.

  198. Sylvia says:

    5 stars
    Made 2 times in as many days! Yesterday for a potluck today for us. Used more Chile and cheese and a larger pan for the potluck … less Chile and cheese but same amount of eggs in the smaller pan for us today boy did it get puffy! Everyone at the potluck loved it and so do we so easy this will be a go to from now on but I will stick to the bigger pan

    1. Nikki Krakauer says:

      Make two pans, whatever your family will eat in one meal, plus lunch leftovers (fabulous re-heated next day!) in one pan, use other to freeze!!! My family adores this stuff, & now my grandkids are wanting a recipe for their own. Blessings!!!

  199. Wendi L says:

    5 stars
    This is SO freaking good! I use finely ground corn in meal in place of the flour because I like the corn element. THANK YOU for making chili rellenos so easy to enjoy at home!

    1. Amy @Belly Full says:

      Happy to hear it!

  200. Ruth says:

    what is the nutritional value of this, esp. the total carbs? thanks

  201. Steve says:

    You can cheat even more and use six small cans of the pre diced chili peppers. Made it this morning using moms “secret” recipe. Use two cans per layer (I do three layers) and I use a small can of condensed milk for a richer flavor along with two tablespoons of butter diced over the three layers.

    1. Nikki Krakauer says:

      I never considered condensed milk! I’m lamenting the fact that I want now, but am out of milk!!! Thank you for saving my mouth a *huge* amount of grief & “bellyaching” ?!!! Blessings!!!

    2. Michele Clow says:

      Did you use sweetened condensed milk or evaporated milk?

      1. Wendy says:

        NOT sweetened condensed.
        Could use evaporated milk or half-and-half in place of whole milk.

    3. Dee says:

      We use the diced chiles as well. And I add either cooked spicy sausage crumbles or ground beef flavored with taco seasoning. Makes it a good brunch or dinner option.

  202. Sandra says:

    To make it keto I used HWC diluted with little water to equal 1 cup, 4 eggs and 1.5 T almond flour…it was delicious

    1. bella says:

      what is hwc?

      1. Koleen D Hansen says:

        HWC to me when thinking Keto would be “heavy whipping cream”.

  203. Becky says:

    Lines the bottom of my casserole dish with roasted hot hatch chiles, topped that with cream cheese and a handful of extra sharp cheddar, then added a pound of Turkey and sauteed onions, then the egg mixture and more extra sharp cheddar. Will see how it turns out

    1. Terrie says:

      I can’t wait to try this.

  204. Jacquie says:

    I may have missed it but what size casserole dish did you use? Was it a 9 x 13? Looks delicious.

    1. Amy @Belly Full says:

      3-quart is written in the directions, so yes.

  205. Carol says:

    5 stars
    Made this a few weeks ago and we loved it. Very light and perfect for summer dinner. My question is can I make this east in the day, refrigerate and bake for dinner?

    1. Aaron W says:

      Wondering why there is so much milk? 1-3/4 cups seems like overkill for 5 eggs.

      1. Pamela says:

        I agree…1 3/4 cup milk seems like a lot. I wished someone had answered this question. One comment mentioned using 8 eggs!! And some said it didn’t set well…too much milk maybe?? Others used evaporated milk. I hesitate to use this recipe until someone verifies that 1 3/4 cup milk is correct.

        1. Amy @Belly Full says:

          Hi Pamela! I’ve made this recipe more times than I can count and it always comes out perfectly. Not sure why some have issues, but if you scroll, you’ll see that plenty of people have made it without any problem, and not modifying it in any way. Not quite sure how to reply to comments questioning the ingredients, when I know it doesn’t need to be adjusted. Thanks!

    2. Kristi Miller says:

      5 stars
      I added shredded chicken ! Amazing

    3. Dot says:

      Just add egg mixture before baking. I even prepar eggs & keep in fridge too. I add green onions to egg mixture!

  206. Lolita says:

    I can’t buy canned whole chiles anywhere. I’ve checked all the grocery stores within a driveable distance. How would I prepare fresh anaheim or poblano chiles to make this casserole?

    1. Jewlee seidl says:

      Roast in the oven on a cookie sheet . When they are done put in a bowl with a wet kitchen towel and wrap chilli in towel and let sweat for 15 to 20 minutes. Remove chilli and peel the skins off. Cut length wise and remove seeds and stem.

    2. Pauline says:

      Does it have to be whole milk ? I only have almond milk.

      1. Amy @Belly Full says:

        I would not favor almond milk in this recipe, but you could try it.

      2. Kaylyn says:

        I have used a plant based milk for this without issues as well as regular milk. I just can’t remember if it was almond or soy.

    3. Miles says:

      Roast them in the oven at 450 on a cookie sheet until the skin bubbles and starts to turn black. Let them cool and peel the skin off.

    4. bibi says:

      Roast them in a pan with a tiny bit of oil or if you have a gas range you can use tongs to hold it over the flame and roast until blackened. Let cool slightly then peel the blackened skins off. You can also try wrapping in a paper towel and microwave maybe 1 minute or 2, let it stand wrapped to steam it, let cool slightly and peel the skins off. After removing skins, cut length of pepper to pen and scrape out all the seeds and vein. You now have your pre diftend, peeled and seeded peppers ready for use.

    5. Denise Sims says:

      I get mine at Cash and Carry, if you have a restaurant food supply place nearby, that is your best bet.

    6. L. says:

      I low broil them ,then wrap in foil
      to sweat the skin off.

    7. Lori F says:

      I had to buy them online. WalMart had them with free shipping.

    8. Holly says:

      you can fire roast them, and then take the skin off.Its hatch chili season here in Texas. They are everywhere!!

    9. Debbie Dant says:

      Same here until I found them on Walmart.com. I ordered 6 cans along with some other hard to find spices and stuff. If you order 35.00 or more you get free shipping. It’s very easy for me to spend that amount on their web site…lol

    10. Gayle says:

      I did find them but not in the big cans like I used to buy

    11. Kate says:

      I buy them at king Soopers (Kroger) in a big can.

    12. Paul Raymond Theriault says:

      5 stars
      Try where the sell pizza dough, they usually have fresh and frozen whole roasted chiles in a clear bag with a twisty tie. (I scoffed when first told this).

  207. Elaine ‘Lainey’Drane says:

    I like the idea of a green sauce instead of the tomatoes also, but cannot find a good recipe for tomatillo sauce. Anyone got any to offer I would love to check them out. They can be sent to llalainia@gmail.com
    Thanx so much ahead of time.

  208. Violet Janssen says:

    5 stars
    This was delicious–you don’t need to make any modifications to it at all because it is delicious just the way it is. I used a large can of green chiles and it was exactly enough for the recipe.

    The time it took to bake was just enough to make some tortillas (because this recipe has almost no carbs) to go with it. Had some for lunch the next day–even better the second day.

    1. Julie Rekieta says:

      I made it per instructions but w 2% milk. Mine took longer than it said to get the eggs cooked and was watery. I drained each chili before using so not sure the problem.

      1. Nikki Krakauer says:

        Your oven may run colder than most. Get a simple oven temp thingy, hang it, (after pre-heating oven to say 350 degrees), then “bake” timer for 8-10 minutes. Open oven, check temperature on thingy (some help naming this thingy, please), & if it’s not 350, it means your oven is either hotter (higher temperature than 350 degrees) or cooler (less than 350 degrees). If either is true, adjust your time in oven or heat level. Remember to post it for reference, so family won’t have problems. HTH!!! Blessings!!!

        1. Terry says:

          It’s called an oven thermometer.

  209. Shelly Dalton says:

    I mix eggs with evap milk, add layer of pimentos and black olives. No flour or baking powder…(GF) Added some cilantro, and cumin.
    Been making this for many years. Serve with cheese crisps…..

    1. Holly B says:

      oh that sounds delish!

  210. Becky says:

    5 stars
    Delicious! I had pepper jack on hand so used that instead of Monterey jack, I think it added a nice extra spiciness. I will try fresh chills next time. Thanks!

  211. Sylvia Hewett Schneider says:

    I’ve been looking for a recipe like this!

    BTW… It’s “chile” with an “e” not “chili” that would be a different kind of deliciousness ?

    I have some frozen whole green chiles from Hatch! I can’t wait to try this out!

    Thanks for sharing ??

    1. Sylvia Hewett Schneider says:

      Oops… Not ??
      That was supposed to be a heart! <3

  212. Irene says:

    Seems like you can add anything. I’d do a rotisserie chicken though.

    1. Kevin says:

      I’ve had it with chicken………it is off the chain.

  213. Beverly Powers says:

    5 stars
    My family loved it. I did not use cheddar cheese, but all Monterey Jack. We are not black pepper fans. Next time I would not do the black pepper. It was a bit much. I loved the easy prep.

  214. Kari says:

    Can you use more than five eggs. Seems like you would want to do at least 8 eggs.

  215. Vanessa alvarez says:

    What are the macros for this meal for each serving

    1. Rickie says:

      What is a macro?

  216. Karen says:

    I made this only I added 1 teaspoon of McCormick Mexican seasoning. But my casserole came out a little oily. But was still quite tasty.

  217. Amy says:

    Could you add shredded chicken to this?

    1. Amy @Belly Full says:

      Sure :)

    2. Nel says:

      5 stars
      Added shredded chicken, black beans and fresh corn off the cob.. Was delicious.

      1. Rosa says:

        Uh uh. Chile is a country in South America.

        1. Lois says:

          Yes it is! But it is also the correct spelling for the chile pepper.

  218. Katherine says:

    Oh, this looks delicious!!

  219. Rhonda Greeson says:

    We have made something like this for years – always very tasty. More often for dinner! But really good the next day, too.

    With the ease of getting Hatch green chile peppers, why use canned? They are readily available (at least in the western half of US) in fall – around Labor Day. Pretty easy to roast – either in the oven, open flame on stove or barbecue. It will kick the recipe up a whole lot in flavor – MUCH better than canned.

    And as a NM gal (lived there 35 years), I have never had a relleno with tomato sauce……hmmm? Green chile sauce, yes. A few diced tomatoes as garnish, yes. Red chile sauce even occasionally – green is my favorite.

    1. Val says:

      THANK YOU! As a NM gal myself, I cringed when I read tomato sauce going on top of rellenos! Must be some weird adaptation for those that don’t readily have fresh chile in their state. Regardless, I look forward to trying this recipe!

      1. Penny Schulze says:

        Absolutely agree…green chili sauce! Better yet…CHRISTMAS! Bey you can’t guess where I live :) …

      2. Kathleen says:

        Rhonda and Val, in Mexico, you would not be served Chile Rellenos a dish that originated in Mexico, without a tomato sauce.

    2. Pegg says:

      My mexican aunt used tomato sauce on her original Rellanos. But her coating was egg whites with flour, beat and then add yolks. Took a lot of time. This sounds great

  220. Jan says:

    5 stars
    This is a fantastic recipe and a great alternative to the real thing and so much less work. Healthier too.

    1. Amy @Belly Full says:

      Sure! Just make sure to roast them first, then remove the seeds and charred skin.

    2. Roy says:

      Really easy to roast and peel pablanos

  221. Lucy says:

    Can I add ground beef to eat?

    1. Amy @Belly Full says:

      I would suggest Italian sausage over beef, but sure! Can’t see why not. Just cook it first.

      1. Sheri says:

        May even chorizo.

        1. cheryl says:

          5 stars
          I added cooked CHORIZO and it was off the hook!

    2. Bj Cohen says:

      You can do them on the stove top, directly over the flame, in the oven under the broiler, or on the grill, just turn them often until completely charred on all sides. Put them in a paper bag or a glass dish covered and let them rest a bit. When they are cool enough to handle rub the char off under running water, this will remove the skin. Remove the stems and seeds and you’re good to go!

  222. Robin R says:

    Ok, where do I find these “peppers”? Are they in the “Mexican” aisle or are they in the aisle with the tomato aisle? When I look in the Mexican Aisle they have only the Jalapeño peppers in the can. Are those the peppers I use or is it something else. Would like to make these tonite!! Thank you!!

  223. Michael Ruiz says:

    If you can get fresh (or frozen) Hatch Chiles, you’re in for a major treat. Ive been doing this for years with these Chiles and never turned out a bad one.

  224. Diane Lindall says:

    5 stars
    I have made this for years (minus the baking powder). Love it! I serve with sour cream and salsa…

  225. Natashka says:

    5 stars
    This is a great potluck dish. I prepare it the night before and cook it in the morning.

  226. Joanne Bruno says:

    Frying anything kind of scares me, if I can have cheesy spicy heavenly chili rellenos WITHOUT frying…I’m into it! Plus everything tastes better in casserole form, I’m convinced.

  227. Ray says:

    The sauce doesn’t have to be tomato-y, in my experience. I’ve had it with ranchera, enchilada, crema…no es importa, como piensome!

    1. Ray says:

      Bad edit: it should say no es importa, ¡como me pienso!

      1. Amy @BellyFull says:

        All three of those toppings sound delicious.

  228. Mom says:

    I haven’t made this in years and forgot how easy it was to prepare with such delicious results. So surprised you remembered this meal.

    1. Amy @BellyFull says:

      I never forget the good stuff!

      1. Raema Watson says:

        5 stars
        Have made this for years….great breakfast dish when we have company in. Sometimes I add bacon bits or sausage to it. Always a hit!

        1. Doris says:

          5 stars
          Just wonderful – loved by all, thank you!

      2. Cheri S says:

        5 stars
        I just made this! I saw it last week and could not stop thinking about it. I looked at several recipes but this one hit me right. It is divine. My store had nothing but tiny cans of chopped green chilies that I did not want. I bought fresh peppers, blanched and sliced them up. I used about 5 large Cubanelle (I bought a couple of Poblano-but too hot to take to pot luck.) I got lucky with this ad-lib idea! I took 1/3 of everything out to make a separate little pan a little spicier for me, now I can’t stop eating it. Only change I would make next time, and there will be one, is to use a smaller pan, 2 quart seems like it would work and casserole would be thicker, maybe add a little garlic, and chili pepper. Other than that it is a tasty, quick, easy, not too many ingredient recipe & came out perfect. Thank you Amy